Stanton Gutters Book online
Repair

Repair or replace? How to read the signs on your gutters

Published

Worn white gutter corner with rust streaks and a gap at the fascia on a brick home

Most gutter problems are repairs. A seam that drips, a downspout that came loose, one stretch that sags after a storm: each of those is an hour or two of work, and the rest of the system can stay where it is.

Replacement is for when the trouble is spread along the whole house, or when the wood behind the gutter has gone soft. Here is how we tell the two apart on a site visit, and how you can make a good guess from your own yard first.

When a gutter repair is enough

A repair makes sense when the problem is in one place and the metal around it is still sound.

  • One leaking seam or corner. The sealant has dried out. We clean the joint, reseal it, and test it with a hose.
  • A loose or missing hanger. The gutter dips in one spot. New hidden hangers screwed into solid wood bring it back up.
  • A downspout pulled off the wall. Usually a strap or two has let go. It gets refastened and checked for clogs.
  • A dent from a ladder or a branch. If water still runs through it, a dent is cosmetic. A crushed section can be cut out and replaced on its own.
  • Water running behind the gutter. Often the gutter is fine and the roof edge is missing a drip edge or flashing.

If you can point to the problem and say "it is right there," you are probably looking at a repair.

When to replace gutters

Replacement is the better call when the same problem shows up in several places, because fixing them one at a time costs more over a few years than starting fresh.

  • Rust or holes along a full run. Steel gutters rust from the inside. Once you see it in three or four spots, the rest is close behind.
  • Seams failing all around the house. Older gutters were built from short sections, so there is a joint every 10 feet or so. When they start to go, they go together.
  • Gutters pulling away from the house in more than one place. That usually means the fascia board behind them is rotting and can't hold a screw.
  • Standing water after cleaning. If a clean gutter still holds water, the slope is wrong along the whole length.
  • Peeling paint, or stains on the siding under the gutter line. Water has been getting behind the gutter for a long time.
  • Age. Aluminum gutters commonly last about 20 years, sometimes longer. If yours are near that and need more than one fix, new ones are the better use of the money.

Check the fascia before you decide

The fascia is the board the gutter is screwed to. In Atlanta, with around 50 inches of rain a year and long humid summers, wet wood does not dry out quickly. A gutter that has overflowed for a few seasons often leaves soft wood behind it.

You can check from a ladder with a screwdriver. Press the tip into the board just above the gutter. Solid wood resists. Rotted wood gives like a sponge.

This matters because new gutters on rotten fascia will sag within a year. If the board is soft, it gets replaced first. That is one reason we look behind the gutter before quoting anything.

A quick way to decide

Walk around the house and count.

  • One or two problem spots, metal otherwise clean: repair.
  • Problems on most sides, or soft fascia in more than one place: replace.
  • Somewhere in between: repair the worst spot now and plan the replacement, so it isn't a surprise.

If you aren't sure which side you are on, that is normal. It is hard to judge from the ground.

Common questions

Can you replace one section of gutter?

Yes. A damaged section can be cut out and replaced without touching the rest, as long as the gutters on either side are sound and the same profile.

How long do aluminum gutters last?

About 20 years is typical. Gutters that are cleaned regularly and hung on solid fascia often last longer.

Should I replace gutters when I replace the roof?

It is worth checking them at the same time. If the gutters are old, doing both together means the roof edge and the gutter line are set up to work with each other.

Want a second opinion?

We will look at the gutters, the fascia and where the water ends up, then tell you plainly whether it is a repair or a replacement. Book online or read more about gutter repair and gutter installation in Metro Atlanta.

Rather have someone look at it for you?

Book online